Meet the Lender Who Runs His P2P Portfolio Like a Business

Nagaraj Agadi

Most people think twice about diving into a new asset class, and rightly so. Is the platform regulated? How does cash get flowing? What happens if the borrower fails to repay? In Episode 6 of Real People, Real Stories (Season Two), host Rajat, from LenDenClub spoke with Mr. Agadi (lending since 11th August, 2025), a Bengaluru-based IT professional with over two decades of tenure at a multinational. What he shared was unusual: a P2P lending strategy that was like a small lending business, complete with his own dashboard, KPIs, and daily ledger.

Here’s what he built, what he learnt along the way, and what other lenders can take from it.

From fixed deposits to a wider mix

Mr. Agadi’s journey was much like many Indian professionals. His parents’ generation had relied mostly on fixed deposits. When Mr. Agadi started working in the early 2000s options were limited and he started with real estate, which was more affordable at the time.
As access to the Internet grew, he ventured into equities. During the pandemic, he got into the derivatives market and got into options and futures. He had experimented with almost all the asset classes and concluded that only a few of them fit in with his lifestyle, time, and skills. This is how he saw it in the context of P2P lending in India when he came across it in early 2025.

Starting small, and staying curious

His introduction to it was almost accidental. Reading about RBI regulation of P2P lending in India in a news article caught his eye, and he read up on how it had fared abroad and why regulation was important. As Rajat noted, RBI had issued Master Directions for NBFC-P2P platforms in 2017 and further tightened them in August 2024.

He started with ₹25,000, spread across loans of four to six months. After six months, the results were underwhelming. He had simply lent and waited.

As an IT professional, he did what he does best. He moved everything into a spreadsheet, built a dashboard, and did simulations. What would happen if repayments flowed directly back to work? What would happen if he spread his money wider?

The KPIs behind his P2P lending strategy

Most conversations with lenders are focused on individual borrowing, which bureau score, which tenure, will this pay back. Mr. Agadi built his own measures.

He interestingly calls “Relending velocity” the rate at which you re-lend repaid principal. To sum it up, as borrowers repay their loans, Mr. Agadi prefers to re-lend the principal received into new lending opportunities. He tracks this process closely to understand how efficiently he is deploying repayments across his portfolio. Principal relending ratio: the proportion of repaid principal he put back to work.

Once the simulations made sense, he expanded his lending book to roughly four times its original size and tracked these metrics from day one.

Rajat explained why this lens makes sense. LenDenClub approves around 3% of the loan applications it receives, each checked against more than 670 data points, from repayment history to average monthly balances. After that screening, predicting whether one borrower will repay is close to impossible for the individual. What the individual can control is how widely they spread their money, and how quickly they re-lend it.

The business lens: interest as revenue, NPAs as cost

Mr. Agadi borrowed an idea from a friend who runs a small business. He thinks of himself as the owner of a lending business, with the platform doing the groundwork of finding and assessing borrowers. In his model:

  • The money he lends is his asset.
  • Repaid principal is capital coming back.
  • Interest received is revenue.
  • NPAs and platform fees are costs.
  • What is left is profit before tax.

He says his dashboard works like a daily ledger, helping him track profit and loss and maintain a balance sheet. When he receives the repayments, daily or even monthly; he makes a note of the principal and the interest received. The dashboard then shows him how much to re-lend and how much he can set aside. This roughly takes him about 10-15 minutes.

Understanding NPAs in P2P lending

NPAs were the moment of doubt in his journey, and are the most common concern Rajat hears from lenders. A loan is only classed as non-performing after 90 days without repayment, so NPAs in P2P lending tend to crop up some months after a lender starts. A cluster can appear seemingly suddenly, and it’s natural to wonder: what changed?
Mr. Agadi saw his early earnings look high before NPAs set in, then normalise. That is a reminder that NPAs in P2P lending are part of the model, not an anomaly. Lenders bear the risk of losing principal and interest.
Measuring earnings was a conundrum. With repayments coming almost daily, a standard XIRR calculation gave numbers that made no sense, so he tracks earnings on deployed principal monthly and quarterly. For context, a diversified portfolio on LenDenClub has historically earned 24% p.a. ANR on average. This is historical performance, not a guarantee of future earnings.

Why diversification in P2P lending matters most

If there was one point both speakers returned to, it was this. The platform limits how much a lender can place in a single loan.In theory, there could be a lender who funds a borrower needing ₹10,000. Instead, the idea lends itself to splitting that ₹10,000 into 20 loans of ₹500.

Diversifying one’s P2P lending doesn’t eliminate risk, but it dampens the impact of defaults. Combined with the regularity of relending, this is the idea that informs Mr. Agadi’s approach. He likes the regular income stream that allows him to rebalance, paired with the observation that P2P lending is uncorrelated with the stock market. Instead of tracking daily F&O or equity swings, he views P2P lending as a safer slice of his portfolio.

What he'd tell other lenders

He acknowledges that many of his friends are sceptics. Some tried their hand at P2P lending, but abandoned the idea at the first stage of lending and waiting. His advice? Take a look at your portfolio at least once a week, just like any other asset class.

He also gave some brutally honest feedback. He’d like a clearer explanation of borrower screening, LenDenClub score and bureau score correlation, and more data on NPA trends and diversification in P2P lending. Rajat agreed that the explanation of P2P lending in India needs work. He added that the LDC score is based on those 670+ parameters, informing the assessment of new-to-credit borrowers without a bureau history.

Building your own P2P lending strategy

  • You don’t need a dashboard of your own to borrow from his experience:
  • Start with an amount that you’re comfortable with, and give it time.
  • Diversify heavily into many loans, and not concentrated loans
  • Relend the principal as and when it comes back to you, to keep the wheel moving
  • Expect NPA, and measure P2P lending performance across a cycle, not the first few months
  • Track a handful of simplistic metrics regularly
View P2P lending as a slice of a diversified portfolio, and not the whole pie. We have a guide on how P2P lending fits into one’s overall asset allocation that goes deeper into this idea.
A P2P lending strategy viewed this way has less to do with calling winners, and more to do with temperament.

Final thoughts

Mr. Agadi described his journey as one from sceptic to convert. His story isn’t one that we’d recommend blindly following. It’s an illustration of how a thoughtful lender engages with P2P lending in India, informed by structure, patience and a healthy appreciation of risk.

If you’re considering embarking on a similar journey, remember Rajat’s final words of wisdom – diversify sufficiently, and don’t put all your eggs in a handful of loans. To truly understand the risks, refer to our explainer on the risks of P2P lending.

Frequently asked questions

What does relending mean, and why is it important?
Relending is the practice of putting the proceeds from repaid (and optionally, accrued) interest back into new loans. Since borrowers repay in installments, relending ensures that a bigger chunk of your capital is out earning interest, and growing your spread. It does not impact the risk profile of any given loan.
Why do NPAs appear months after I begin lending?
A loan is typically declared non-performing after 90 days of non-repayment. As such, NPAs in P2P lending tend to surface a few months into the process. This impacts the overall yield trajectory, and skews early perceptions of yield potential.
How many loans should I spread my money?
There is no magic number, but the broader the spread, the better. LenDenClub has a cap on exposure to any given loan to encourage diversification in P2P lending (e.g. a ₹10,000 loan split as 20 loans of ₹500)

LenDenClub is India’s largest peer to peer lending platform which started operations in India in 2015. We have been helping lenders diversify their portfolio beyond traditional investment instruments ever since.


LenDenClub is India’s largest Peer to Peer (P2P) lending platform, operating since 2015. We are an RBI-registered NBFC-P2P connecting individual lenders with verified borrowers across India. Lenders on our platform earn interest income that is not market-linked, making P2P lending a complement to traditional financial instruments.

*Annualized Returns shown are historical on closed loan portfolios.

LenDenClub, operated by Innofin Solutions Pvt Ltd (ISPL) is registered as a peer-to-peer lending non-banking financial company (“NBFC-P2P”) with the Reserve Bank of India (“RBI”). The Reserve Bank of India does not accept any responsibility for the correctness of any of the statements or representations made or opinions expressed by Innofin Solutions Private Limited, and does not provide any assurance for repayment of the loans lent through its platform.
Registration Number: N-13.02267.

LenDenClub is an Intermediary under the provisions of the Information Technology Act, 2000 and virtually connects lenders and borrowers through its electronic platform via the website and/or mobile app.

The lending transaction is purely between lenders and borrowers at their own discretion, and LenDenClub does not assure loan fulfilment and/or lending simple interest. Also, the information provided on the platform is verified or checked on the best efforts basis without guaranteeing any accuracy of the data/information verification. Any lending decision taken by a lender on the basis of this information is at the discretion of the lender, and LenDenClub does not guarantee that the loan amount will be recovered from the borrower, fully or partially. The risk is entirely on the lender. LenDenClub will not be responsible for the full or partial loss of the principal and/or interest of lenders’ lending amounts.

 

*P2P lending is subject to risks. And lending decisions taken by a lender on the basis of this information are at the discretion of the lender, and LenDenClub does not guarantee that the loan amount will be recovered from the borrower.

CIN: U74999MH2015PTC266499.